The Best Potato Salad Recipe

To this day, my mom makes the Best Potato Salad that I have ever had. The texture is both slightly chunky and creamy all at the same time.

And the dressing that coats the potatoes has the perfect ratio of mayonnaise and mustard. Add in a little crunch of celery and onion, and you have the perfect side dish to serve at your backyard cookout!

Over the years I have watched her make the potato salad in awe. I have never seen her follow an exact recipe. Instead, she prepares it all by memory, look and taste.

So when I first asked her for the recipe, she told me what ingredients that she uses. However the measurement instructions were less than defined.

Although she told me add ‘some mayo and mix in a little mustard’, I had to keep practicing until I finally found the correct mix that tastes just like her recipe.

And now, many years later, I am proud to say that I can share this delicious recipe with all of you! So this summer, when you are preparing a backyard cookout for your family and friends, be sure to keep this recipe handy. You can bet that someone will ask you for it!

Best Potato Salad Recipe

*Specific measurements and complete recipe instructions are located in a printable recipe card at the bottom of this article. However, be sure to continue to read the tips and tricks to making this recipe below.

INGREDIENTS

• 5 pounds Yukon Gold or Russet potatoes
• 2 cups Mayonnaise or Miracle Whip
• 1 cup Pickle Relish, sweet or dill flavored
• 2 tablespoons prepared Yellow Mustard
• 1 tablespoon Apple Cider Vinegar
• 2 teaspoons Celery seeds
• 3 ribs of Celery, diced
• 1/2 cup red or sweet Onion, diced
• 5 hard boiled Eggs
• Salt and pepper, to taste

Garnish Ingredients (optional)

• 1 tablespoon fresh chopped dill
• 1/2 teaspoon paprika

Frequently Asked Questions About The Ingredients

Before we get to the actual instructions, let me first answer a few questions that you might have about the ingredients.

1. Type of Potatoes Used

Although you could use any type of potato to make potato salad, I find that it is best to use Yukon gold potatoes. The potatoes will hold up to the cooking process and will give you a nice blend of slightly chunky and slightly creamy potatoes.

However, if you like a more creamy salad, then it is best to use Russet potatoes. They have a higher starch content and will break down more when cooked.

2. Type of Mayonnaise

Whenever I share this recipe or my macaroni salad recipe, I always get asked what is the best type of mayo to use. And my answer is always the same.

Use whatever mayonnaise that you like the best. Yes, it is a general answer but it is true.

If you love Duke’s Mayonnaise, use that. If you prefer Miracle Whip over mayo, then by all means use that instead. And for those who have an egg allergy or who eat a vegan diet, use plant based mayo.

3. What Type of Relish To Use?

Another common question is what type of relish to use. If you like sweeter tasting potato salad, it would be best to use sweet pickle relish.

Like a little more dill flavor? Then use dill pickle relish. Most store bought jars of relish are dill pickle relish. Therefore, that is what I use because I have it already on hand in my refrigerator.

4. Is Apple Cider Vinegar Necessary?

This is one ingredient that you don’t want to skip. I know it may sound weird, but adding a little apple cider vinegar will provide that slight tang that potato salad is known for.

However, it must be apple cider vinegar and not distilled white vinegar that you use. There is a significant difference in taste between the two.

So now that you know more about the ingredients, let’s get to the actual recipe instructions!

COOKING INSTRUCTIONS

Wash and scrub the potatoes clean. Now decide whether or not that you want to peel the potatoes.

If you are using Yukon gold potatoes, you can leave the peels on if you prefer. They are thin enough and will not cause a texture issue.

However, it is best to peel Russet potatoes, either before or after they have been boiled. That is because this variety of potato has a thicker skin that doesn’t mix well in potato salad.

Now dice the potatoes into 1/2 inch chunks. Some people quarter the potatoes and then cut them after they cook. However, I find it easier to do it before. But the choice is up to you.

Place the potatoes in a large stockpot and cover with cold water, at least 1 inch above the potatoes. Then place the pot over high heat and bring the water to a boil.

Once boiling, add 1/2 tablespoon of salt to the water and cook the potatoes for 8-10 minutes, if they are cut in small cubes. Be sure to increase the boil time for larger potatoes. You want the potatoes tender enough that a fork can easily pierce through to the other side.

While the potatoes are boiling, prepare the dressing. In a medium size bowl add the mayonnaise/Miracle Whip, pickle relish, yellow mustard, apple cider vinegar, celery seeds, paprika, salt and pepper to taste.

Then stir the potato salad dressing until the ingredients are well incorporated. Set aside. Then dice the celery, onions, & dill, set aside.

Now it is time to peel and dice the hard boiled eggs. You can use an egg slicer, or a sharp knife to cut the eggs into small pieces.

Assembly Instructions

Once the potatoes are done cooking, drain them in a colander. Remove as much moisture that you can and let them sit in the colander to cool slightly for 5 minutes.

Then place the potatoes in a large serving bowl. Add the diced celery, onions, dill, and eggs to the bowl.

Then slowly pour half of the dressing over top of the mixture. Gently toss the potato salad and pour in the remaining dressing.

Continue to toss until the potatoes are well coated. Add salt and black pepper per taste. Then garnish with fresh dill and paprika.

Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours before serving. However, it is best to let the potato salad to sit overnight for maximum flavor.

Keep it in the refrigerator until ready to serve. If you are serving it for a backyard cookout, be sure to leave it out no longer than 2 hours at room temperature or it will spoil.

Enjoy! Mary

Follow My Facebook Page For Great Recipes! Make Your Meals Facebook Page

To receive our 3 Recipe Articles in your inbox each week, sign up for our free email list located in the middle of each recipe or email me at contact@makeyourmeals.com. You can also follow us on Facebook and Pinterest. This article may contain affiliate links where a small commission is paid if you purchase a product at no additional cost to you.